Trimech-Main-Site-Group-Navigation Solid-Solutions-Group-Navigation Javelin-Group-Navigation Trimech-Enterprise-Solutions-Group-Navigation Trimech-Advanced-Manufacturing-Group-Navigation Trimech-Staffing-Solutions-Group-Navigation Solid-Print-Group-Navigation 3DPRINTUK-Group-Navigation 3DVERKSTAN-Group-Navigation Macdac-Site-Group-Navigation GRM-Consulting-Group-Navigation Solid-People-Group-Navigation
The TriMech Group offers a comprehensive portfolio of engineering and design software, hardware, professional services, and support, to clients accross the globe. Use the links above to visit the group's websites and learn more.
x

Comparing 3D printing technologies: Is Bambu the right fit for your application? 

Comparing 3D printing technologies: Is Bambu the right fit for your application? Ever since its entry into the 3D printing market, Bambu Lab has impressed with its beautifully designed machines that make printing easy and enjoyable.

Solid Print3D

April 2, 2024

Ever since its entry into the 3D printing market, Bambu Lab has impressed with its beautifully designed machines that make printing easy and enjoyable. High print speeds, user-friendly operation and flexible connectivity are just some of the key benefits these machines provide. But with the rapid innovations in 3D printing technology and the wealth of options that are now available, there may be other choices worth considering for your particular application. 

In this series of three blog posts we’ll be taking a look at the most popular 3D printing technologies and exploring how users can choose between them, depending on their specific needs. We’ll compare capabilities, features and benefits to help identify the best choices for a range of applications. 

Bambu Lab X1 Carbon Combo Print Farm Bundle -1

Overview of 3D Printing Technologies

The term 3D printing covers various technologies that build components layer-by-layer. These technologies typically differ in the way they form the components, the types of materials they work with, the surface finish and durability of the components they produce, operating costs and printing speed. These are the technologies that are most widely used at the present time: 

1.FFF printing (Fused Filament Fabrication) is one of the most common and affordable desktop 3D printing technologies. It works by extruding thermoplastic filament through a heated print head to build parts layer by layer. Key benefits are low cost, variety of materials, and ease of use. 

2. SLA printing (Stereolithography) uses a UV laser to cure liquid resin layer by layer, producing highly detailed parts with smooth surfaces. Although it is ideal for small, complex parts like jewellery, dental models and tabletop gaming pieces, it is a more expensive and complicated process than FFF. 

3. SLS printing (Selective Laser Sintering) uses a laser to fuse powdered material. It can produce both plastic and metal parts. It produces durable parts with exceptionally good mechanical properties and, although it is more expensive than some of the alternatives, it is often preferred for industrial applications. 

4. MJF printing (Multi Jet Fusion) is an industrial powder bed technology that jets fusing and detailing agents to bind polymer powder. It offers fast build speeds, isotropic properties and accuracy across XYZ axes. It is currently the leading technology for the manufacture of consistent, production-quality parts. 

5. DLP printing (Digital Light Processing) uses a projector to flash images of each layer in the component onto a vat of liquid resin. The resin is selectively cured by the light, producing finely detailed parts faster than SLA. It is the most affordable of the photo-polymerization technologies currently on the market. 

6. Binder Jetting uses liquid binding agent sprayed in precise locations to fuse powder material layer by layer. It is capable of producing fully coloured parts in materials that include metal, sandstone and ceramic. Low cost per part makes it suitable for short-run production. 

Popular technologies compared

The most popular 3D printing technologies are FFF, SLS and SLA printing, each of which comes with its own strengths and limitations. We’ll now look at these three technologies in a little more detail. 

Ultimaker New Product Lineup

FFF printing, sometimes called FDM, is the most common and cost-effective technology for desktop 3D printing. It is an ideal entry-level choice for start-up businesses, schools and even individuals with a passion for 3D printing, thanks to low initial and operating costs which it combines with reasonable printing speed. FFF printers can use a variety of materials from PLA and ABS to flexible, wood and metal-fill filaments. And these printers are environmentally friendly, producing less waste than other technologies.  

As well as offering many benefits, FFF has some downsides – print resolution usually limited, especially on the vertical Z-axis, and there are often visible lines in the printed parts. With entry level machines, the size of the parts that can be printed will be restricted by the small bed size. 

Solid Print 3D - SLS Bureau - Formlabs - Fuse 1 - 3D Printing - 3D - Manufacturing - Warwickshire - Warwick - Coventry - Leamington Spa - Rugby

SLS printing yields parts with excellent mechanical properties and high dimensional accuracy. This makes it a good choice for producing durable end-use parts. The SLS process works by using a CO2 laser to selectively fuse powdered material like nylon, glass-fill or aluminium. Unfused powder provides support during printing, enabling complex geometries to be achieved.  

Benefits of SLS printing include increased isotropic material strength as the powder is fused not layered. SLS printing is suitable for printing larger components and can be used with a wide range of materials. These benefits are offset by high printer cost, which limits the adoption of SLS mainly to industrial applications. In addition, parts produced by SLS printing have a rough surface finish which may need sanding and polishing. There is also significant material waste from unsintered powder left over at the end of the printing process. 

SLA printing cures liquid resin layer-by-layer to build highly detailed 3D models. The uncured resin provides natural support during the print process. SLA is unmatched when it comes to accuracy, smoothness and the production of intricate designs. This technology offers exceptionally high print resolution and precision with smooth surface finishes that don’t have visible layer lines.  

Limitations of SLA printing include higher cost of ownership than FFF desktop printers, and print size constrained by smaller build volumes. The brittle materials it uses are prone to breaking under stress, and the resins used can be messy to handle, requiring gloves and ventilation. Uncured resin waste needs proper disposal which may incur extra costs.  

In summary

As discussed above, FFF, SLS and SLA printing technologies each have unique capabilities aligned to different applications and business objectives. Determining the right fit depends on assessing needs in relation to accuracy, material types, part size, operating costs and post-processing effort required. 

In our next blog post we’ll attempt to answer the difficult questions when it comes to FFF printing, FDM, SLS, SLA and their capabilities and look at some practical examples, and in our last instalment will be looking at what kind of technology best suits your application in practice – from producing durable end-use parts, and composite materials to prototypes and delicate artwork or ceramics. 

So, whether you’re looking to adopt 3D printing for rapid prototyping, digital manufacturing or advanced research and development projects, this three-part blog series will provide the answers you need, allowing you to choose the solution that best aligns to your goals and delivers the outputs you expect. 

Still wondering which 3D Printing technology is right for you?

previous arrowprevious arrow
next arrownext arrow
 

Let us help!

Want to find out more about services and support programmes for your business? The friendly experts at Solid Print3D are happy to help!

How it works …

  • Discuss your business needs with our technical experts
  • Take a tour of best-in-class products at our HQ, based on your interest
  • Arrange for your samples to be printed for assessment and see 3D scanning in action
Banner Here

Rapid Prototyping: Introduction Guide

Haven’t you thought to yourself about the history behind every mass-produced object around you? Something that began in someone’s mind, someone’s imagination, is now in the palm of yours and countless consumers hands. To make mass production possible, manufacturers had …

Learn More

Wazer — World’s First Workbench Water Jet Cutter

Wazer is the world’s first workbench water jet cutter. It has brought the power of water within everyone’s reach. We like to tout 3D printing as an up-and-coming replacement for traditional CNC machining. Although additive manufacturing can significantly lower costs …

Learn More

Troubleshooting Most Common 3D Printing Issues

How to troubleshoot the most common 3D printing issues? And how to avoid them altogether with support? Discover solutions with Solid Print3D.

Learn More
Solid Print3D Ltd Building 500, Abbey Park, Stareton, Kenilworth, Warwickshire, CV8 2LY Copyright © 2024 Solid Print3D All Rights Reserved.
01926 333 777 sales@solidprint3d.co.uk